Breaking Bad News · Case 6

Breaking Bad News OSCE - Multiple Sclerosis Diagnosis

Diagnosis: Multiple Sclerosis Diagnosis

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 31-year-old female
  • Occupation: Accountant
  • Setting: Neurology outpatient clinic, results appointment, attending alone
  • Chief complaint: "I'm here for my MRI results"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 31, I'm an accountant, and I live with my partner. We're hoping to start trying for a baby next year.

What Brings Me In

"I've come back for the results of my scans. They did them after the problem with my eye."

My Story

About three months ago I woke up with a dull ache behind my right eye that got worse when I moved the eye. Over the next few days the vision in that eye went blurry, like looking through frosted glass, and colours looked washed out — red looked almost brown. I went to the eye emergency clinic and they said it was inflammation of the nerve at the back of the eye, and that it usually gets better on its own. It did: it took about six weeks to come back to nearly normal, though red still looks a little duller in that eye. The eye doctor referred me here, and I had scans of my brain and neck about four weeks ago, plus some blood tests and a test where I watched a chequerboard on a screen.

When I saw the neurologist the first time, I mentioned that about two years ago I had pins and needles and numbness in both legs, up to my waist, for about three weeks. I'd just started training for a half-marathon and put it down to that. It went away on its own and I never saw anyone about it.

I've looked online. I know a scan can show a tumour, or 'white spots' that can mean MS. I get migraines with zigzag lights a few times a year, and I read that migraines can cause white spots too, so I'm hoping that's all it is. I've also been very tired, but I started a new job four months ago with long hours, so I think that's why.

I've come on my own because my partner couldn't get the time off work. I'd rather you were straight with me.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: migraine with aura since her teens (3–4 attacks a year); right optic neuritis 3 months ago; nothing else
  • Medications: sumatriptan 50 mg when needed for migraine; desogestrel 75 micrograms daily (progestogen-only pill)
  • Allergies: none known
  • Social: smokes 5 cigarettes a day and is trying to cut down; drinks about 8 units a week; lives with her partner; drives to work; runs twice a week
  • Family history: mother has an underactive thyroid; no family history of MS or other neurological conditions

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I'm hoping the spots are from my migraines, but deep down I'm scared it's MS or a brain tumour."
  • "If it is MS, does that mean I'll end up in a wheelchair? That happened to someone I used to work with."
  • "We want to try for a baby next year. Can I still do that, and would I pass it on?"
  • "Will I be able to keep driving and working?"
  • "If it's bad news I'll probably go quiet and tearful at first. I'd need a moment before you tell me about treatments."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Vision now: "Nearly back to normal. Red looks a bit duller in my right eye, especially after a hot shower or a run."
  • Eye pain: "That's gone completely."
  • Double vision: "No."
  • Leg numbness: "Two years ago, both legs up to my waist, for about three weeks. Nothing since."
  • Neck bending: "Now you mention it, sometimes when I bend my head forward I get a buzzing down my back."
  • Bladder: "I sometimes have to rush to the loo, but I thought that was normal."
  • Weakness or balance: "No, I'm still running."
  • Tiredness: "Very tired, but I've got a new job with long hours." (red herring)
  • Headaches: "My usual migraines, three or four a year, with zigzag lights first. Nothing new." (red herring)
  • Pregnancy: "I'm not pregnant. We're hoping to try next year."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: well, anxious; BP 118/74 mmHg, HR 84 bpm
  • Visual acuity: right 6/9, left 6/6; colour vision (Ishihara) right 13/17 plates, left 17/17
  • Pupils: mild right relative afferent pupillary defect
  • Fundoscopy: temporal pallor of the right optic disc; left disc normal
  • Eye movements: full, no nystagmus or internuclear ophthalmoplegia
  • Limbs: normal tone and power; reflexes brisk but symmetrical; plantars flexor; vibration sense mildly reduced at both great toes
  • Coordination and gait: normal; Romberg's test negative

Investigations

  • MRI brain with gadolinium: 11 ovoid T2-hyperintense lesions — 6 periventricular (several perpendicular to the lateral ventricles), 3 juxtacortical, 2 infratentorial (left middle cerebellar peduncle and pons); one right periventricular lesion enhances with gadolinium and the rest do not (dissemination in space, and in time on a single scan)
  • MRI cervical spine: one short T2 lesion at C3 occupying less than half the cord's cross-section (spinal cord involvement; fits her neck-flexion symptom)
  • Visual evoked potentials: delayed P100 latency in the right eye (128 ms, normal below 115 ms); left normal (confirms previous right optic nerve demyelination)
  • Aquaporin-4 and MOG antibodies: both negative (argues against neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder and MOG antibody disease)
  • Bloods: vitamin B12 410 ng/L, TSH 2.1 mU/L, ANA negative, serum ACE normal, HIV and syphilis serology negative, FBC, U&E and LFTs normal (mimics excluded)
  • Vitamin D: 31 nmol/L (insufficient)
  • Urine dipstick: no leucocytes or nitrites (no infection to explain bladder urgency)

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (McDonald criteria)
    • Evidence: two separate attacks in different parts of the central nervous system (sensory symptoms in both legs two years ago; right optic neuritis three months ago), objective signs of the optic neuritis (right RAPD, disc pallor, delayed VEP), MRI lesions in all four typical areas (dissemination in space), and enhancing and non-enhancing lesions together (dissemination in time); Lhermitte's symptom, heat-related blurring and bladder urgency fit
  • Differentials:
    • Migraine-related white matter lesions: usually small and subcortical, do not enhance and do not involve the spinal cord
    • Neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder or MOG antibody disease: both antibodies are negative and the cord lesion is short rather than longitudinally extensive
    • Small vessel disease: unlikely at 31 without vascular risk factors other than light smoking, and the lesion pattern is typical of demyelination
    • Vitamin B12 deficiency, sarcoidosis or lupus: blood tests are normal
    • Brain tumour: her main fear; multiple small lesions without mass effect do not suggest a tumour

Management

  • Prepare: a private room without interruptions; offer to phone her partner or rearrange so he can be present; tissues to hand
  • Find out what she knows and how much she wants to know; she has asked for directness
  • Give a warning shot ("I'm afraid the scans have shown something we need to talk about"), then say clearly that this is multiple sclerosis; pause and let silence and emotion happen before going on
  • Acknowledge and name her feelings; check understanding; give information in small chunks; ask what matters most to her today
  • Address her concerns: most people with relapsing-remitting MS do not need a wheelchair, and treatment reduces relapses and slows disability; life expectancy is close to normal; MS does not affect fertility, relapses tend to fall in pregnancy and rise in the 3 months after birth, and a child's risk of MS is about 2%
  • Disease-modifying therapy: she has active disease, so offer treatment, chosen together at follow-up around her pregnancy plans; glatiramer acetate or interferon beta suit someone planning pregnancy, while teriflunomide and fingolimod are avoided
  • Lifestyle: stop smoking (linked to faster progression); start vitamin D supplementation; keep exercising; heat can briefly bring back old symptoms
  • Relapses: explain that a relapse is new or worsening symptoms lasting over 24 hours without infection, and to contact the MS team; disabling relapses can be treated with a short course of high-dose methylprednisolone
  • Driving and work: she must tell the driving licensing authority and her insurer, and most people keep driving; she has the right to reasonable adjustments at work and can choose when to tell her employer
  • Refer to the MS specialist nurse, give written information and reputable charity resources, and book follow-up within 2–4 weeks with her partner invited; offer pelvic floor advice for bladder urgency
  • Summarise, check what she will tell her partner and give a contact number

Key Learning Points

  • MS is diagnosed by dissemination in space and time after excluding mimics; one MRI showing enhancing and non-enhancing lesions can show dissemination in time, and asking about past neurological episodes often reveals an earlier attack.
  • After optic neuritis, check aquaporin-4 and MOG antibodies, because neuromyelitis optica and MOG antibody disease are treated differently and some MS drugs make them worse.
  • Break bad news with a structure such as SPIKES: set up the room, check perception and invitation, give a warning shot and plain words, respond to emotion, and close with a clear plan and support, addressing her real concerns (wheelchair, pregnancy, driving and work).