Cardiovascular · Case 4
Cardiovascular OSCE - Aortic Stenosis
Diagnosis: Aortic Stenosis
Case Overview
- Age/Sex: 81-year-old female
- Occupation: Retired seamstress
- Setting: GP surgery
- Chief complaint: "My chest goes tight and I come over dizzy when I walk"
Patient Script
Who I Am
I'm 81, a retired seamstress, and I've lived on my own since my husband died three years ago.
What Brings Me In
"When I walk up the hill to the shops my chest goes tight and I come over dizzy, and I have to stop until it passes."
My Story
About four months ago I noticed that walking up the hill to the shops, about 200 metres, gave me a tight feeling across the middle of my chest, like a band. If I stop and stand still it goes within two or three minutes. It has never come on when I'm resting. Now it comes on sooner, after about 100 metres or one flight of stairs.
With the tightness I sometimes feel dizzy and lightheaded. Two weeks ago I was carrying my shopping up the steps to my front door when everything went grey. I grabbed the railing and sat down on the step, and it cleared after about a minute. I didn't fall or black out completely. I'm also more breathless walking than I used to be.
The doctor said years ago that I had a murmur but it was nothing to worry about. Six months ago I started amlodipine for my blood pressure, and since then my ankles swell a little by the evening and I sometimes feel woozy getting out of bed, so I wondered if it's the tablet. My knees are bad with arthritis, which slows me down anyway, and I do get indigestion after a big dinner.
My Medical Background
- Past medical history: high blood pressure for 10 years; osteoarthritis of both knees; high cholesterol; no heart attacks or strokes; no rheumatic fever that she knows of
- Medications: amlodipine 5 mg once daily (started 6 months ago); atorvastatin 20 mg at night; paracetamol 1 g up to four times a day for her knees; an over-the-counter antacid when needed
- Allergies: penicillin (rash)
- Social: never smoked; a small sherry at Christmas; lives alone in a bungalow; independent with shopping, cooking and washing; walks to the shops; does not drive
- Family history: sister had a heart attack at 75
What I Think & Worry About
- "I think it's my new blood pressure tablet making me dizzy, or I'm just getting old."
- "I'm worried I'll black out properly and nobody will find me, living on my own."
- "I don't want to go into a home. I want to stay independent, but I'm not sure about having an operation at my age."
If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...
- Chest tightness: "Across the middle, like a band, about 5 out of 10. It doesn't spread anywhere and goes when I stop."
- Dizziness: "Only when I'm walking or climbing, and the time on the steps when everything went grey."
- Breathing: "Puffed on the hill. I sleep on my usual two pillows and I don't wake up gasping."
- Palpitations: "No, my heart doesn't race or flutter."
- Ankles: "A bit puffy by bedtime since the new tablet, gone by morning." (red herring)
- Getting out of bed: "Sometimes woozy for a second when I stand up quickly, but the bad dizziness is on the hill." (red herring)
- Indigestion: "Only after a big meal, and the antacid sorts it. That's different from the tightness." (red herring)
- Knees: "They ache, but it's my chest and dizziness that stop me on the hill, not my knees."
- Fevers or weight loss: "No."
- Teeth: "I have dentures on top and a few of my own teeth at the bottom."
Clinical Summary
Examination
- General: alert, comfortable at rest; BMI 24 kg/m2
- Heart rate: 74 bpm, regular; slow-rising, low-volume carotid pulse
- Blood pressure: 118/90 mmHg lying and 116/88 mmHg after 3 minutes standing (narrow pulse pressure; no postural drop)
- Respiratory rate: 16/min
- Oxygen saturation: 96% on room air
- Temperature: 36.5 °C
- Heart: harsh grade 3/6 ejection systolic murmur loudest at the right upper sternal edge, radiating to both carotids; quiet second heart sound; heaving, non-displaced apex beat
- JVP not raised; chest clear
- Mild pitting oedema of both ankles (in keeping with amlodipine; the JVP is not raised and the chest is clear, so there is no sign of heart failure)
Investigations
- ECG: sinus rhythm 74 bpm; left ventricular hypertrophy by voltage criteria with lateral ST depression and T-wave inversion (strain pattern); PR interval 180 ms (no heart block)
- Echocardiogram (urgent): heavily calcified trileaflet aortic valve; peak velocity 4.6 m/s, mean gradient 54 mmHg, valve area 0.7 cm2 (severe aortic stenosis); concentric left ventricular hypertrophy; ejection fraction 60%; mild mitral regurgitation
- NT-proBNP: 1,280 ng/L (raised)
- Haemoglobin: 126 g/L (no anaemia)
- Creatinine: 88 µmol/L, eGFR 54 mL/min/1.73m2 (mildly reduced; relevant before contrast imaging)
- TSH: normal; HbA1c: 39 mmol/mol (normal)
- Later, before intervention: CT angiography shows suitable femoral access; coronary angiography shows mild non-obstructive coronary disease
Diagnosis
Primary diagnosis: Severe symptomatic calcific aortic stenosis
- Evidence: age 81 with a long-known murmur; four months of progressive exertional chest tightness, exertional presyncope and breathlessness; slow-rising pulse with narrow pulse pressure; ejection systolic murmur radiating to the carotids with a quiet second sound; LVH with strain on ECG; echo showing a peak velocity of 4.6 m/s, mean gradient 54 mmHg and valve area 0.7 cm2.
Differentials:
- Stable angina from coronary artery disease: can coexist, but the murmur and echo explain her symptoms, and angiography shows only mild disease.
- Orthostatic hypotension from amlodipine: her bad dizziness comes on with exertion rather than posture, and there is no postural drop.
- Bradyarrhythmia or heart block: pulse regular at 74 bpm with a normal PR interval; ambulatory ECG if any doubt remains.
- Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: the murmur radiates to the carotids, the second sound is quiet, and echo shows a calcified valve rather than septal hypertrophy with outflow obstruction.
- Aortic sclerosis: causes a murmur without obstruction, with a peak velocity below 2.5 m/s, far lower than hers.
- Gastro-oesophageal reflux: her indigestion follows big meals and settles with an antacid, whereas the tightness comes on with exertion and goes within minutes of rest.
Management
- In general practice: an ejection systolic murmur with exertional chest pain and near-syncope needs urgent echocardiography and cardiology review.
- Advise her to avoid strenuous exertion and heavy lifting until assessed, and to call 999 for chest pain at rest, fainting or breathlessness at rest.
- Do not start nitrates or other strong vasodilators, which can cause a sharp fall in blood pressure in severe aortic stenosis; review her blood pressure treatment cautiously with cardiology.
- Continue atorvastatin and paracetamol; avoid NSAIDs for her knees.
- Definitive treatment: symptomatic severe aortic stenosis needs aortic valve intervention, as medicines do not change its course and untreated survival is poor once symptoms begin.
- The heart team decides between transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) and surgical replacement; at 81 with suitable femoral access, TAVI is usually preferred.
- Work-up: CT angiography for access and valve sizing, coronary assessment, frailty assessment and a dental check.
- Afterwards: single antiplatelet therapy (aspirin or clopidogrel) if there is no other indication for anticoagulation, echo follow-up, good dental hygiene, and advice to report fever because of endocarditis risk.
- Discuss her wishes about independence openly; offer a falls alarm while she waits.
Key Learning Points
- The classic symptoms of severe aortic stenosis are exertional angina, exertional syncope or presyncope, and breathlessness; once they appear, prognosis without valve intervention is poor.
- A slow-rising pulse, narrow pulse pressure, a quiet second heart sound and LVH on ECG all point to severe disease; echo confirms it with a peak velocity of 4 m/s or more, mean gradient of 40 mmHg or more, or valve area below 1 cm2.
- Older age alone is not a reason to withhold treatment: TAVI offers a less invasive option, and the heart team decides with the patient.