Chest Pain · Case 10

Chest Pain OSCE - Shingles (Herpes Zoster)

Diagnosis: Shingles (Herpes Zoster)

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 58-year-old female
  • Occupation: Primary school teaching assistant
  • Setting: GP surgery, same-day appointment
  • Chief complaint: "Burning pain around my left side, and now a rash"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 58, I work as a teaching assistant in a primary school, and I live with my husband.

What Brings Me In

"I've had a burning pain round my left side for a few days, and now a rash has come up in the same place."

My Story

It started four days ago with a burning, stinging pain in a band going from the middle of my back on the left, round my side, to under my left breast. It's about 6 out of 10 and it's there most of the time, with sharp, shooting jabs every so often. The skin there is really sensitive — even my bra strap or my top brushing against it is horrible. I felt tired and a bit fluey at the start, achy with a mild headache.

The first night I worried it was my heart because it was in my chest, but it didn't get worse when I walked about and I wasn't breathless, so I took paracetamol and waited. Yesterday morning I noticed red blotches in the same strip, and by the evening they had little blisters on them. A few more have come up today.

The week before this started I'd been carrying heavy boxes of books at school, so I thought I'd strained something. I also changed to a new washing powder a couple of weeks ago and wondered whether the rash was a reaction to that, but it's only on the left side and the pain came first. I've been under a lot of stress — my mum moved into a care home last month and I've been clearing her house.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: high blood pressure for 6 years; heartburn now and then; chickenpox as a child; never had shingles before; no problems with my immune system, no cancer
  • Medications: amlodipine 5 mg once daily; paracetamol 1 g up to four times a day for the past 4 days; antacid when needed
  • Allergies: none known
  • Social: non-smoker; drinks about 6 units a week; lives with my husband; works closely with children aged 4 to 7; menopause at 52, not on HRT
  • Family history: father had a heart attack at 72; mother has dementia
  • Family: my daughter is 28 weeks pregnant and is due to visit this weekend

What I Think & Worry About

  • "At first I thought it might be my heart. Now I wonder if it's an allergy or something catching."
  • "My daughter is 28 weeks pregnant and I don't think she ever had chickenpox. Can I still see her this weekend? I'd never forgive myself if I harmed the baby."
  • "I need to know if I can go to work, and I want something that takes this pain away."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Pain: "Burning and stinging, like a bad sunburn, with sharp jabs. Clothes rubbing make it worse."
  • Site: "A strip from the left side of my back round to under my left breast. Nothing at all on the right."
  • Timing: "The pain for four days, the rash since yesterday morning."
  • Exertion: "Walking and stairs don't make it worse."
  • Breathlessness, palpitations or sweating: "No."
  • Itch: "It's a bit itchy too."
  • Face and eyes: "No rash on my face, and my eyes are fine."
  • Fever: "I felt fluey and achy at the start, but I don't think I had a temperature."
  • Headache: "A mild one at the start, gone now."
  • Weakness or numbness elsewhere: "No."
  • Weight loss, night sweats or frequent infections: "No."
  • Heartburn: "I get it sometimes after a big meal, but this isn't like that." (red herring)
  • Heavy lifting: "I carried boxes of books last week — I thought I'd pulled something." (red herring)
  • New washing powder: "I changed it about two weeks ago." (red herring)

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: well, uncomfortable, holding her top away from her skin
  • Temperature: 37.4 °C
  • Heart rate: 82 bpm, regular
  • Blood pressure: 136/82 mmHg
  • Respiratory rate: 14 breaths per minute
  • Oxygen saturation: 98% on room air
  • Skin: clusters of small vesicles, some merging, on a red base in a band over the left T5 dermatome, from the left paravertebral area round the lateral chest wall to below the left breast; stops at the midline front and back; no crusting yet; no lesions elsewhere on the body
  • Sensation: allodynia over the same dermatome
  • Face and eyes: no lesions on the forehead or tip of the nose; eyes white, vision normal
  • Cardiovascular: heart sounds normal, no murmurs
  • Respiratory: chest clear, equal air entry

Investigations

  • 12-lead ECG: sinus rhythm 82 bpm, no ST or T-wave changes (done because the pain began as chest pain; no evidence of ischaemia)
  • Capillary blood glucose: 5.8 mmol/L (normal)
  • Renal function (hypertension review 3 months ago): creatinine 68 µmol/L, eGFR above 90 (no antiviral dose adjustment needed)
  • Vesicle swab for varicella-zoster virus PCR: not sent (a painful vesicular rash in one dermatome after a pain prodrome is a clinical diagnosis; swab if the rash is atypical or she is immunocompromised)

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: herpes zoster (shingles) of the left T5 dermatome
    • Evidence: four days of unilateral burning, shooting pain with allodynia in a band from the back to under the breast, followed by a vesicular rash on a red base confined to the same dermatome and stopping at the midline; age over 50; recent stress; previous chickenpox
  • Differentials:
    • Acute coronary syndrome: chest pain in a 58-year-old with hypertension, but the pain is burning, constant and not exertional, the ECG is normal and the rash follows a dermatome
    • Contact dermatitis from the new washing powder: would itch more than it hurts, sit wherever clothing touches on both sides, and would not follow days of nerve pain
    • Musculoskeletal strain: the lifting is a red herring; the pain is burning with allodynia and a dermatomal rash
    • Zosteriform herpes simplex: possible, but she has no history of recurrent cold sores or blisters in this area
    • Reflux: her heartburn is meal-related and does not explain the pain on the side and back or the rash

Management

  • Antiviral: she is over 50 and within 72 hours of the rash appearing, so offer aciclovir 800 mg five times a day for 7 days (alternatives: valaciclovir 1 g three times a day or famciclovir 500 mg three times a day, each for 7 days)
  • Pain: continue paracetamol; add ibuprofen 400 mg three times a day with food for a short course if needed; if pain stays severe or neuropathic, offer amitriptyline 10 mg at night, duloxetine, gabapentin or pregabalin
  • Skin care: keep the rash clean and dry, wear loose cotton clothing, cover lesions with a loose non-adherent dressing, and avoid topical antibiotic or antiviral creams
  • Infection control: shingles cannot be caught as shingles, but fluid from the blisters can give chickenpox to someone who is not immune; she is infectious until every lesion has crusted, usually 5–7 days after the rash appears
  • She should not see her pregnant daughter until all lesions have crusted; her daughter should tell her midwife or GP about any contact so her immunity can be checked and post-exposure treatment considered
  • Work: with a covered rash on the trunk she does not need to stay off, but she should tell her school, because non-immune pregnant colleagues and immunosuppressed children must avoid contact until the lesions crust; offer a fit note if the pain stops her working
  • Explain postherpetic neuralgia (pain lasting beyond 3 months, more common with age), which early antivirals may reduce
  • Safety-netting: return urgently for rash on the face or near the eye, eye pain or change in vision, spread beyond this band, a high fever, signs of skin infection, or uncontrolled pain; review in a week if not settling
  • Once recovered, discuss the recombinant shingles vaccine when she becomes eligible under the national programme

Key Learning Points

  • The pain of shingles often comes days before the rash and can mimic cardiac, pleural, biliary or renal pain; a burning, band-like, one-sided pain with skin sensitivity in a dermatome should make you look for, and warn about, a rash.
  • Offer oral antivirals within 72 hours of rash onset to people over 50, those with moderate to severe pain or rash, non-truncal involvement or immunosuppression; ophthalmic involvement (Hutchinson's sign) needs same-day eye assessment.
  • Counsel on infectivity until the lesions crust: keep away from non-immune pregnant women, newborns and immunosuppressed people, who can catch chickenpox from the blisters.