Chest Pain · Case 11
Chest Pain OSCE - Spontaneous Pneumothorax
Diagnosis: Spontaneous Pneumothorax
Case Overview
- Age/Sex: 19-year-old male
- Occupation: Apprentice electrician
- Setting: Walk-in centre with on-site X-ray
- Chief complaint: "Sharp pain on the right side of my chest when I breathe"
Patient Script
Who I Am
I'm 19, I'm an apprentice electrician, and I live with my mum and my younger brother.
What Brings Me In
"Last night I got a sudden sharp pain on the right side of my chest. It hurts when I breathe in, and I've been a bit out of breath since."
My Story
It started last night at about 9 o'clock, so about 14 hours ago. I was just sitting on the sofa playing on my console, not doing anything physical, when I suddenly got a sharp, stabbing pain on the right side of my chest, under my armpit and towards the front. It came on in an instant. It was about 7 out of 10 at first and it's about 4 out of 10 now. It's much worse when I take a deep breath or cough, so I've been taking little breaths. I've been a bit short of breath since, especially on the stairs, and it feels like I can't fill the right side of my chest properly. I didn't sleep well. I thought it would be gone by the morning but it hasn't, so my mum told me to come here before work.
On Tuesday I spent the day carrying heavy drums of cable on a job, so I thought I might have pulled a muscle, though it didn't hurt at the time. I've also had a bit of a tickly cough this week because my brother has a cold. I get anxious sometimes and had a panic attack before my driving test last year, but this feels different — I'm not panicking, it just hurts to breathe.
My Medical Background
- Past medical history: none; no asthma or other lung problems; never had a collapsed lung; no operations
- Medications: none; took paracetamol 1 g this morning, which helped a little
- Allergies: none known
- Social: smokes cannabis most evenings, rolled with tobacco, for about 3 years; also smokes about 5 cigarettes a day; drinks around 12 units at weekends; no other drugs; works on building sites; plays football at weekends; height 1.91 m, weight 68 kg
- Family history: father has high blood pressure; no lung conditions or blood clots in the family
What I Think & Worry About
- "I thought I'd pulled a muscle at work, but it isn't going away."
- "I'm a bit worried it's my lungs — my mum keeps saying the weed will wreck them."
- "I'm meant to be flying abroad with my mates in 10 days, and I need to get back to work. Will I still be able to go?"
If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...
- Site: "Right side, under my armpit and round to the front."
- Onset: "Sudden. One second I was fine, the next it hurt."
- Breathing: "It catches when I breathe in deeply, and I'm a bit puffed on the stairs."
- Spread: "Sometimes it goes up to the tip of my right shoulder."
- Left side: "No, the left side feels completely normal."
- Fever: "No, I haven't felt hot or shivery."
- Coughing up blood: "No."
- Palpitations or fainting: "No."
- Legs and travel: "No pain or swelling in my legs, and no long journeys."
- Injury: "I haven't been hit, fallen or had any accident."
- Weight loss or night sweats: "No."
- Cough: "A little tickly cough from my brother's cold, nothing coming up." (red herring)
- Heavy lifting: "I carried cable drums on Tuesday, but it didn't hurt at the time." (red herring)
- Anxiety: "I had a panic attack before my driving test, but this is different — I'm not panicky and my fingers aren't tingling." (red herring)
Clinical Summary
Examination
- General: tall, slim young man (BMI 18.6 kg/m²), alert, talking in full sentences, wincing on deep breaths
- Heart rate: 94 bpm, regular
- Blood pressure: 124/76 mmHg
- Respiratory rate: 20 breaths per minute
- Oxygen saturation: 96% on room air
- Temperature: 36.7 °C
- Trachea: central; apex beat not displaced
- Right hemithorax: reduced expansion, hyper-resonant to percussion, reduced breath sounds and vocal resonance
- Left hemithorax: normal expansion, resonant, normal vesicular breath sounds
- Cardiovascular: heart sounds normal; JVP not raised
- Chest wall: no tenderness, bruising or surgical emphysema
- Legs: calves soft and non-tender
Investigations
- PA chest X-ray: right-sided pneumothorax with a visible visceral pleural edge; interpleural distance 3 cm at the level of the hilum (large by the 2 cm threshold); no mediastinal shift; no visible underlying lung disease; left lung normal
- 12-lead ECG: sinus rhythm 94 bpm, normal axis, no ST or T-wave changes
- Arterial blood gas: not needed (saturations above 92% on air, no respiratory distress)
- Chest X-ray after needle aspiration (in hospital): right lung re-expanded with a residual apical rim under 1 cm (successful aspiration)
Diagnosis
- Primary diagnosis: right primary spontaneous pneumothorax
- Evidence: sudden right-sided pleuritic pain at rest with mild breathlessness in a tall, thin young man who smokes cannabis and tobacco; reduced expansion, hyper-resonance and reduced breath sounds on the right; a visible pleural edge with a 3 cm rim on chest X-ray
- Differentials:
- Tension pneumothorax: must be excluded at once; the trachea is central, he is not hypotensive or hypoxic, and there is no mediastinal shift
- Musculoskeletal strain: Tuesday's lifting is a red herring; the onset was at rest, the chest wall is not tender and the signs and X-ray show a pneumothorax
- Pneumonia or pleurisy: he is afebrile, the cough is dry and mild and there is no consolidation
- Pulmonary embolism: no risk factors or leg signs, and the X-ray explains his symptoms
- Panic attack: no tingling or hyperventilation, and there are objective chest signs
Management
- At the walk-in centre: confirm there are no features of tension; give oxygen only if saturations fall below 94%; arrange same-day transfer to the emergency department for respiratory assessment
- He has symptoms (pain and breathlessness) but no high-risk features (no haemodynamic compromise, significant hypoxia, bilateral pneumothorax, underlying lung disease, haemothorax, or age 50 or over with a significant smoking history), so by BTS guidance the options, chosen with him, are conservative care with close review, an ambulatory drainage device, or needle aspiration
- He chose needle aspiration (16–18G cannula in the second intercostal space, mid-clavicular line, or in the safe triangle), which succeeded on repeat X-ray; a chest drain is needed if aspiration fails or high-risk features develop
- Discharge with analgesia (paracetamol and ibuprofen) and written advice; respiratory clinic review with a chest X-ray in 2–4 weeks
- Smoking: stopping cannabis and tobacco is the most effective way to cut his risk of recurrence; refer to the local stop-smoking service
- Air travel: he should not fly until a chest X-ray confirms full resolution, and many airlines ask for a further week after that, so the holiday in 10 days may need to move
- Diving: avoid permanently unless he has definitive surgery; avoid heavy lifting at work until reviewed
- Recurrence: about 1 in 3 have another pneumothorax; refer for surgery (video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery with pleurodesis) after a recurrence or a persistent air leak
- Safety-netting: return immediately or call an ambulance if breathlessness or pain gets worse
Key Learning Points
- Primary spontaneous pneumothorax typically affects tall, thin young men, often smokers (cannabis and tobacco both raise the risk); sudden pleuritic pain with reduced breath sounds and hyper-resonance on one side should prompt an urgent chest X-ray.
- Always check for tension (tracheal deviation, hypotension, hypoxia); tension needs immediate decompression before any imaging.
- Current BTS guidance bases management on symptoms and high-risk features rather than size alone; conservative care, ambulatory devices and needle aspiration are all options in stable primary pneumothorax, followed by advice on smoking, flying and diving.