Collapse / Syncope · Case 6

Collapse / Syncope OSCE - Carotid Sinus Hypersensitivity

Diagnosis: Carotid Sinus Hypersensitivity

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 79-year-old male
  • Occupation: Retired postman
  • Setting: Falls clinic, referred by his GP after four falls in three months; his wife has come with him
  • Chief complaint: "I keep ending up on the floor"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 79, a retired postman, and I live with my wife in a two-storey house; I still drive and look after the garden.

What Brings Me In

"I've been having funny turns where I end up on the floor. It's happened four times in three months, so my GP sent me here."

My Story

The first one was about three months ago. I was shaving at the bathroom mirror, stretching my neck to get the razor under my chin, and the next thing I knew I was on the bathroom floor with my wife knocking on the door. I didn't feel it coming, and I can't have been out long because the shaving foam was still on my face.

The second was about six weeks ago in the garden. A neighbour called out from over the fence and I turned my head sharply to look back. I had a swimmy feeling for a second, then I was lying on the lawn. My wife saw that one from the kitchen window: she said I went grey, dropped like a stone, was out for about 10 seconds, then came round and was talking sense straight away.

The third was at a family wedding a month ago, a few minutes after I'd done up my top button and tightened my tie. I was standing at the bar and went down, and I bruised my left hip. The last one was a week ago: I was looking up into a high kitchen cupboard and went down, catching my left cheek on the worktop, which is this bruise. Each time I've been myself again within a minute or two, and I've never had chest pain or a racing heart with them.

My GP started a tablet for my waterworks about two months ago, and I wondered if that's to blame, because I sometimes feel a bit light-headed getting up in the night for the toilet. My eyesight isn't great, I'm waiting for a cataract operation, and my knees are arthritic, so part of me thinks I'm just tripping.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: high blood pressure for 15 years; enlarged prostate; arthritis in both knees; cataracts in both eyes, on the waiting list; no heart attacks, strokes or mini-strokes; no diabetes or epilepsy
  • Medications: lisinopril 10 mg once daily; atorvastatin 20 mg at night; tamsulosin 400 micrograms once daily (started two months ago); paracetamol when my knees are bad
  • Allergies: none known
  • Social: live with my wife; independent with everything; walk without a stick; drive locally; stopped smoking 30 years ago (about 20 pack-years); about 5 units of alcohol a week, all on Sundays
  • Family history: my father died of a stroke at 80; no sudden deaths in the family

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I think I'm probably just tripping because of my eyes and knees. I'm 79, after all."
  • "My wife thinks it's more than that, and she's worried I'll crack my head next time."
  • "I'm worried about losing my licence. I don't know how we'd manage without the car."
  • "I'd like to know what's causing it and whether it can be stopped."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Getting up: "A little light-headed if I get up quickly in the night, but I sit on the edge of the bed first and I've never fallen then."
  • Fits: "My wife saw no shaking. No wet trousers, no bitten tongue, and I wasn't muddled afterwards."
  • Dizziness and stroke symptoms: "No spinning, double vision, weakness, numbness or trouble speaking."
  • Driving: "I've never had one in the car, thank goodness. I drive to the shops and to see the grandchildren."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: alert and well; fading bruises over the left cheekbone and left hip; abbreviated mental test score 10/10
  • Heart rate: 68 beats per minute, regular
  • Blood pressure: 148/82 mmHg lying; 142/80 mmHg at 1 minute and 140/82 mmHg at 3 minutes standing, without symptoms (no orthostatic hypotension)
  • Respiratory rate: 14 breaths per minute; oxygen saturation 97% on room air
  • Temperature: 36.6 °C
  • Cardiovascular: normal heart sounds; no murmur, in particular no ejection systolic murmur of aortic stenosis; no carotid bruits
  • Neurological: normal cranial nerves, power, sensation and coordination; Romberg negative
  • Gait: steady without aids; timed up and go 11 seconds
  • Eyes: visual acuity 6/18 right and 6/12 left; bilateral cataracts

Investigations

  • 12-lead ECG: sinus rhythm at 66 beats per minute; PR 184 ms, QRS 98 ms, QTc 420 ms; no bundle branch block or other conduction disease
  • 24-hour ambulatory ECG (arranged by his GP): sinus rhythm throughout, rate 52–104 beats per minute, no pauses over 2 seconds, occasional ventricular ectopics, no symptoms during the recording
  • Echocardiogram: mild concentric left ventricular hypertrophy; ejection fraction 60%; aortic sclerosis without stenosis (peak velocity 1.9 m/s)
  • Bloods: Hb 139 g/L, Na 138 mmol/L, K 4.5 mmol/L, creatinine 98 µmol/L, glucose 5.4 mmol/L, TSH 2.1 mU/L (all normal)
  • Carotid sinus massage (no bruits and no stroke or TIA in the last 3 months; 10 seconds each side in turn, supine and at 60° head-up tilt, with continuous ECG and beat-to-beat blood pressure): right side when tilted gave a 4.6-second asystolic pause and a systolic fall from 144 to 86 mmHg (58 mmHg), reproducing his swimmy feeling (positive: mixed response with a dominant cardioinhibitory component); left side gave a 2.0-second pause and a 30 mmHg fall

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Carotid sinus syndrome (symptomatic carotid sinus hypersensitivity), mixed type with a dominant cardioinhibitory response

    • Evidence: recurrent, abrupt loss of consciousness with little or no warning in an older man, each time triggered by neck pressure or movement (shaving under the chin, sharp head turning, a tight collar, looking up); witnessed pallor with brief unconsciousness and rapid full recovery; normal ECG, Holter and echo; no orthostatic hypotension; carotid sinus massage giving a 4.6-second pause and a 58 mmHg systolic fall with his usual symptoms
  • Important differentials (and reasoning):

    • Orthostatic hypotension, including from tamsulosin: no postural drop on testing, none of the turns happened on standing up, and the first turn came before tamsulosin was started
    • Intermittent heart block or sick sinus syndrome: normal ECG conduction and Holter, though an implantable loop recorder is still worth considering if turns continue after treatment
    • Aortic stenosis: causes exertional syncope; he has no murmur and the echo shows sclerosis without stenosis
    • Mechanical falls from poor vision and knee arthritis: his wife witnessed a true loss of consciousness with pallor
    • Seizure: no jerking, incontinence, tongue biting or post-ictal confusion
    • Vertebrobasilar TIA: no vertigo, double vision, slurred speech or focal signs, and isolated loss of consciousness is rarely a TIA

Management

  • Explain the diagnosis: an over-sensitive pressure sensor in the neck artery slows or briefly stops the heart and drops the blood pressure when the neck is pressed or turned
  • Pacing: refer for a dual-chamber permanent pacemaker, the guideline-supported treatment for recurrent, unpredictable syncope with injury from cardioinhibitory carotid sinus syndrome; the blood pressure (vasodepressor) part can persist, so some symptoms may continue
  • Avoid triggers: loose collars and no tight ties; sit down to shave and use an electric razor; turn the whole body rather than twisting the neck; avoid looking up for long; sit or lie down at the first swimmy feeling
  • Medication review: stop tamsulosin, an alpha-blocker that adds to blood pressure falls, and consider finasteride instead; avoid over-treating his blood pressure
  • Driving: he must stop driving now and tell the driving licence authority; cardiology will advise when he can return after pacing
  • Falls prevention: multifactorial assessment, including expediting cataract surgery, a home hazard visit, strength and balance training, bone health (fracture risk assessment, vitamin D) and a personal alarm
  • Safety-netting: seek urgent help for more frequent blackouts, a head injury or chest pain

Key Learning Points

  • Carotid sinus hypersensitivity is a common cause of unexplained falls and syncope in older people. Ask about shaving, tight collars and head turning, and remember that older patients often do not recall losing consciousness and report only a fall.
  • Diagnose it with carotid sinus massage under continuous ECG and blood pressure monitoring, lying and upright: a pause of 3 seconds or more, or a systolic fall over 50 mmHg, is positive, and reproducing symptoms makes it carotid sinus syndrome. Do not massage when there is a carotid bruit or a stroke or TIA in the last 3 months.
  • Dual-chamber pacing reduces syncope in the cardioinhibitory type, but also stop vasodilating drugs and address every other falls risk.