Joint Pain · Case 7
Joint Pain OSCE - Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
Diagnosis: Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
Case Overview
- Age/Sex: 26-year-old female
- Occupation: Primary school teaching assistant
- Setting: GP surgery, routine appointment
- Chief complaint: "Painful joints" with a facial rash and tiredness
Patient Script
Who I Am
I'm 26, I work as a teaching assistant in a primary school, and I share a flat with a friend.
What Brings Me In
"My joints have been aching for a few months, I've got this rash on my face that won't go, and I'm so tired I can barely get through the school day."
My Story
About three months ago my hands and wrists started aching, and then my knees. It's both sides, and it comes and goes: some weeks it's my fingers, other weeks my knees. My fingers sometimes look a little puffy, and I'm stiff for about half an hour in the morning.
About five weeks ago I came back from a sunny week away with a red rash across my cheeks and the bridge of my nose. I thought it was sunburn, but it hasn't faded, and it flares when I'm out in the sun. I'd started a new face cream just before the trip, so I wondered if it was that, but I stopped it and the rash is still there.
The tiredness is the worst thing. I sleep well but I'm exhausted by lunchtime. I've had a few evening temperatures, around 37.8 °C. I've noticed more hair coming out in my brush, and I've had a couple of painless ulcers on the roof of my mouth. My fingers go white, then blue when I'm cold, which never used to happen. A child in my class had slapped cheek about two months ago, and a parent told me it can cause joint pains in adults. I've also been vegetarian for two years, so I wondered if I'm short of iron.
My Medical Background
- Past medical history: none; never pregnant; no blood clots
- Medications: contraceptive implant in my arm (progestogen-only, put in 18 months ago); paracetamol when needed, which helps a little
- Allergies: none known
- Social: teaching assistant; non-smoker; about 6 units of alcohol a week; vegetarian; lives with a flatmate; normally plays badminton but has stopped
- Family history: my aunt has rheumatoid arthritis; my mum has an underactive thyroid
What I Think & Worry About
- "I thought I'd caught slapped cheek from school, or that I'm run down and short of iron. I'm worried it's something more than that, because the rash just won't go."
- "I'm scared it's something serious and long-term, and I'm worried about having children one day if it is."
- "I want to know what's going on, and I'd like something to help me cope with work."
If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...
- Pain score: "Most days about 4 or 5 out of 10, worse in the mornings."
- Chest: "No chest pain, even when I take a deep breath."
- Breathing: "I'm not breathless."
- Swelling: "My ankles aren't swollen."
- Urine: "My wee looks normal, not frothy or dark, and I'm passing the usual amount."
- Weight: "I've lost about 2 kg, I think because I'm off my food."
- Eyes and mouth: "My eyes and mouth aren't dry."
- Headaches or fits: "No bad headaches, no fits, no confusion."
- Glands: "There's a small lump in my neck that comes and goes."
- Bleeding or bruising: "No unusual bruising or bleeding, and my periods are light with the implant."
- Mood: "I'm a bit down and frustrated, but no thoughts of harming myself."
- Pregnancy: "I'm not trying for a baby, and I don't think I could be pregnant."
Clinical Summary
Examination
- General: tired-looking; weight 60 kg
- Temperature: 37.6 °C
- Heart rate 92 beats per minute, regular; blood pressure 118/74 mmHg; respiratory rate 14 breaths per minute; SpO2 99% on air
- Skin: erythematous rash across both cheeks and the nasal bridge, sparing the nasolabial folds, without scarring or scale (malar rash)
- Mouth: a painless shallow ulcer on the hard palate
- Scalp: diffuse non-scarring hair thinning
- Hands: mild swelling and tenderness of the 2nd and 3rd metacarpophalangeal joints and wrists on both sides; no deformity
- Knees: tender on both sides, no effusion
- Lymph nodes: small mobile cervical lymph nodes
- Cardiorespiratory examination: normal heart sounds, no pericardial or pleural rub, chest clear
- No peripheral oedema; abdomen soft, no hepatosplenomegaly
- Urine dipstick: no protein or blood
Investigations
- Full blood count: Hb 108 g/L, MCV 87 fL (normocytic anaemia); WCC 3.1 ×10⁹/L (leucopenia) with lymphocytes 0.8 ×10⁹/L (lymphopenia); platelets 135 ×10⁹/L (mild thrombocytopenia)
- Ferritin: 45 µg/L (normal; iron deficiency is not the cause)
- Direct antiglobulin test: negative (no haemolysis)
- ESR: 55 mm/hour (raised); CRP 6 mg/L (normal, a pattern typical of active lupus)
- ANA: positive at 1:640, homogeneous pattern
- Anti-double-stranded DNA: 180 IU/mL (positive, high)
- Anti-Sm antibodies: positive
- Complement: C3 0.6 g/L and C4 0.08 g/L (both low, suggesting active disease)
- Antiphospholipid antibodies: lupus anticoagulant, anticardiolipin and anti-beta-2 glycoprotein I all negative
- Parvovirus B19 IgM: negative
- Renal function: creatinine 64 µmol/L (normal); urine protein to creatinine ratio 12 mg/mmol (normal)
- TSH: 2.0 mU/L (normal)
- Pregnancy test: negative
Diagnosis
Primary diagnosis: Systemic lupus erythematosus
- Evidence: a young woman with inflammatory polyarthralgia and mild synovitis of the hands and wrists, a photosensitive malar rash sparing the nasolabial folds, painless palatal ulcers, non-scarring alopecia, Raynaud's phenomenon, low-grade fevers and fatigue, with leucopenia, lymphopenia and thrombocytopenia, a high-titre ANA, positive anti-dsDNA and anti-Sm, and low complement. She comfortably meets the 2019 classification criteria.
Differentials:
- Parvovirus B19 arthropathy: her school contact is a red herring; parvovirus can cause a symmetrical arthritis and a positive ANA, but IgM is negative and anti-dsDNA, anti-Sm and low complement point to lupus.
- Rheumatoid arthritis: hand and wrist synovitis fits, but the rash, ulcers, cytopenias and serology do not; the aunt's history is a red herring.
- Contact dermatitis or rosacea: the rash persisted after stopping the face cream, is photosensitive and spares the nasolabial folds.
- Iron deficiency from a vegetarian diet: ferritin is normal and iron deficiency does not cause cytopenias of all three cell lines or a rash.
- Drug-induced lupus: she takes no causative drug, and anti-dsDNA is usually negative in drug-induced lupus.
- Lymphoma: fevers, lymph nodes and cytopenias are worth considering, but the nodes are small and mobile and the antibody profile explains the picture; review if nodes enlarge.
Management
- Explain the likely diagnosis honestly: lupus is a long-term autoimmune condition that is treatable, and many people live full lives with it.
- Refer urgently to rheumatology, given the cytopenias and systemic features. There is no sign of organ-threatening disease (normal urine, renal function, chest and neurology), so admission is not needed today.
- Rheumatology will usually start hydroxychloroquine, recommended for almost everyone with lupus (at most 5 mg/kg/day of actual body weight, so no more than 300 mg daily at 60 kg; 200 mg daily is usual) with retinal screening, and may add a short course of prednisolone or another immunosuppressant.
- Symptom relief while waiting: paracetamol, and a short course of naproxen 250 to 500 mg twice daily with food if needed, as renal function is normal.
- Sun protection: broad-spectrum SPF 50 sunscreen, a hat, and avoiding midday sun, since UV light triggers flares.
- Raynaud's: keep the hands warm and wear gloves.
- Contraception and pregnancy: her progestogen-only implant is suitable; antiphospholipid antibodies are negative, but oestrogen-containing methods still need a specialist view. Advise planning any pregnancy with rheumatology when the disease is quiet.
- Recheck urinalysis, blood pressure and renal function at every review to pick up lupus nephritis early; assess cardiovascular risk.
- Offer influenza and pneumococcal vaccines before immunosuppression.
- Safety-net: seek urgent review for chest pain on breathing, breathlessness, ankle swelling, frothy or reduced urine, severe headache, confusion, a fit, bleeding or bruising, or a high fever.
Key Learning Points
- Suspect SLE in a young woman with inflammatory joint pain plus systemic features such as a photosensitive malar rash, mouth ulcers, alopecia, Raynaud's, fatigue and fever. A raised ESR with a normal CRP is a typical clue.
- ANA is sensitive but not specific; anti-dsDNA and anti-Sm are specific, and low complement and a rising anti-dsDNA suggest active disease.
- Screen every patient with lupus for kidney involvement with urinalysis and blood pressure at each visit, and check antiphospholipid antibodies, which shape contraception and pregnancy planning.