Musculoskeletal · Case 4

Musculoskeletal OSCE - Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury

Diagnosis: Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 22-year-old female
  • Occupation: Physiotherapy student; plays netball for a club team
  • Setting: Sports injury clinic, 12 days after injury
  • Chief complaint: "I twisted my knee at netball and heard a pop"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 22, a third-year physiotherapy student, and I play netball for a club team three times a week.

What Brings Me In

"I hurt my left knee at netball twelve days ago — I heard a pop and it swelled up like a balloon. It's better, but it keeps giving way when I turn."

My Story

Twelve days ago, in a match, I landed from a jump to catch the ball and pivoted on my left leg to pass. My knee twisted inwards, I heard and felt a loud pop, and I went straight down. The pain was about 8 out of 10 and I couldn't carry on playing. Within about an hour the knee had swollen up massively. I went to an urgent treatment centre that evening; they X-rayed it, said nothing was broken, and gave me crutches and an appointment here.

The swelling has gone down a lot and I'm walking without the crutches now, but the knee feels unstable. Twice this week it gave way — once turning round in the kitchen and once stepping off a kerb — and both times it was painful and swelled up a bit again. It hasn't locked, and I can almost straighten it fully but not quite. Going down stairs feels wobbly.

My teammate, who saw it happen, thinks my kneecap popped out, because that happened to her last year. I sprained my left ankle last season, but that's fully better. I also had painful lumps below both kneecaps when I was about 13, which the doctor said was a growing problem.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: left ankle sprain last season, fully recovered; painful bumps below both kneecaps at 13 that settled; otherwise well
  • Medications: combined contraceptive pill; ibuprofen 400 mg and paracetamol when needed since the injury
  • Allergies: none known
  • Social: lives in a shared house with stairs; non-smoker; 6–8 units of alcohol at weekends; trains three times a week, wants to keep playing at a high level; on placement next month
  • Family history: nothing relevant; no blood clots in the family

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I'm worried I've done my cruciate ligament, because we learned about it on my course, but my teammate thinks it's my kneecap."
  • "I'm scared I'll miss the rest of the season, or never play at the same level again. Netball is a big part of my life."
  • "I want to know exactly what's damaged, and whether I need an operation or whether physio alone could work."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Swelling: "It came up within an hour, really tight and big."
  • Locking: "It's never got stuck. It just gives way."
  • Giving way: "Twice this week, both times when I turned or twisted."
  • Weight-bearing: "I couldn't walk on it that day, but I can now with a limp."
  • Pain: "Mostly a deep ache inside the knee, about 3 out of 10 now, worse after giving way."
  • Kneecap: "I didn't see it move, and nobody had to push it back in."
  • Previous knee injury: "No, never hurt this knee before."
  • Calf: "No calf pain or swelling."
  • Numbness: "My foot feels normal."
  • Other joints: "No other joint problems."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • Gait: mildly antalgic, full weight-bearing without aids
  • Heart rate: 68 beats per minute; blood pressure 112/70 mmHg; temperature 36.5 °C
  • Left knee inspection: moderate effusion with a positive sweep test; no bruising; no deformity
  • Palpation: no joint line tenderness; no tenderness over the medial or lateral collateral ligaments or the medial patellar retinaculum
  • Range of movement: 5° to 115° (lacks the last 5° of extension, no springy block)
  • Lachman test: increased anterior translation compared with the right, with a soft end point
  • Anterior drawer test: positive
  • Pivot shift: not tolerated because of guarding
  • Posterior drawer: negative; no posterior sag
  • Valgus and varus stress at 0° and 30°: stable
  • Patella: central, patellar apprehension test negative
  • McMurray's test: negative, limited by flexion
  • Neurovascular: normal sensation and pulses in the foot; calf soft and non-tender
  • Right knee: normal

Investigations

  • Left knee X-rays (day of injury): no fracture; no avulsion of the lateral tibial plateau (Segond fracture); no lipohaemarthrosis; patella normally sited
  • MRI of the left knee: complete mid-substance rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament; bone bruising of the lateral femoral condyle and posterolateral tibial plateau (pivot-shift pattern); menisci intact; collateral ligaments and posterior cruciate ligament intact; medial patellofemoral ligament intact; moderate effusion

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Complete rupture of the left anterior cruciate ligament

    • Evidence: non-contact pivoting injury on landing, an audible pop, immediate inability to continue, swelling within an hour (haemarthrosis), episodes of giving way on turning, a positive Lachman test with a soft end point and positive anterior drawer, and MRI confirming a complete tear with the typical bone bruising.
  • Differentials:

    • Patellar dislocation: her teammate's idea; but the patella is central, there is no medial retinacular tenderness, the apprehension test is negative and the medial patellofemoral ligament is intact on MRI.
    • Meniscal tear: twisting injuries commonly cause one, but meniscal swelling usually builds over a day; she has no locking or joint line tenderness and the menisci are intact on MRI.
    • Medial collateral ligament sprain: valgus stress is stable and there is no medial tenderness.
    • Tibial plateau fracture: X-rays show no fracture.
    • Posterior cruciate ligament injury: posterior drawer negative, no sag.
    • Osgood-Schlatter disease (the lumps below her kneecaps at 13): an apophysitis of the tibial tuberosity that settles when growth ends, and it causes neither an effusion nor instability.

Management

  • Explain the diagnosis: the ACL does not heal by itself, so the decision is between structured rehabilitation alone and ACL reconstruction followed by rehabilitation.
  • Refer to an orthopaedic knee surgeon. For a young athlete in a pivoting sport with giving way, reconstruction is usually recommended, but the choice is shared and depends on her goals.
  • Start physiotherapy now (prehabilitation): reduce swelling, regain full extension and quadriceps control. Surgery goes better once the knee has full range and little swelling.
  • Analgesia: paracetamol 1 g up to four times a day and ibuprofen 400 mg three times a day with food for a short course; ice, compression and elevation.
  • Avoid pivoting and cutting sports until rehabilitation is complete. Return to netball after reconstruction usually takes 9 to 12 months, guided by strength and hop testing.
  • She takes the combined pill: flag it for venous thromboembolism risk assessment at pre-operative assessment, and review contraception if immobilisation is expected.
  • Safety-net: return for locking, a sudden increase in swelling, fever, or calf pain or swelling.
  • On return to sport, follow a neuromuscular injury-prevention programme to cut the risk of re-injury and injury to the other knee.

Key Learning Points

  • A pop, immediate inability to play and swelling within a few hours mean a haemarthrosis; in adults the commonest cause is an ACL rupture.
  • The Lachman test is the most sensitive bedside test; pain and swelling limit the acute examination, so re-examine at one to two weeks, and use MRI to confirm the tear and find meniscal or collateral injuries.
  • Management is individual: reconstruction suits people with instability who want to return to pivoting sports, and early rehabilitation matters either way.