Musculoskeletal · Case 5

Musculoskeletal OSCE - Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Diagnosis: Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 47-year-old female
  • Occupation: Self-employed hairdresser
  • Setting: GP surgery, routine appointment
  • Chief complaint: "My hand keeps going numb and waking me up at night"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 47, I've been a hairdresser for nearly thirty years, I rent a chair in a salon, and I'm right-handed.

What Brings Me In

"My right hand has been tingling and going numb, mostly at night. It wakes me two or three times and I have to shake it to get the feeling back."

My Story

About four months ago I started waking in the night with pins and needles in my right hand. It's in my thumb, index and middle fingers, and I think half of my ring finger too; my little finger is fine. It feels like the hand has gone to sleep, sometimes with a burning feeling, and there's an ache that creeps up into my forearm. I hang my hand over the side of the bed and shake it, and after a few minutes the feeling comes back. At first it was once or twice a week; now it's most nights, two or three times a night.

In the day it comes on when I've been holding scissors or a hairdryer up for a long time, and when I'm driving or holding my phone. Over the last month I've started dropping things — a comb, a cup of tea — and fiddly jobs like doing up earrings are harder because I can't feel what I'm doing. My left hand tingles now and then, but nothing like the right.

My neck and shoulders ache at the end of a long day standing over clients, which is why I wondered about a trapped nerve. I've also had sore, cracked skin on both hands for years from hair dyes and shampoos. I've put on about 6 kg in the last two years, and my periods have become irregular this past year with the odd hot flush.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: hand dermatitis from hair products; asthma as a child, none since; no diabetes or thyroid trouble that I know of
  • Medications: emollient cream and hydrocortisone 1% cream when my hands flare; ibuprofen now and then for the forearm ache (it doesn't touch the tingling)
  • Allergies: no medicine allergies; my skin reacts to some hair dyes
  • Social: works five days a week, long hours standing; self-employed with no sick pay; never smoked; about 6 units of alcohol a week; lives with my husband and teenage son; drives
  • Family history: my mother has type 2 diabetes and an underactive thyroid; my aunt had a stroke in her 70s
  • Periods: irregular for a year; not pregnant (my husband has had a vasectomy)

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I think it might be a trapped nerve in my neck, or maybe the start of arthritis."
  • "If I can't hold my scissors I can't work, and if I don't work I don't get paid. My aunt's stroke started with a numb hand, and that's been in the back of my mind."
  • "I'm hoping for something that doesn't mean weeks off. I've heard there's an operation and I'd rather avoid it if I can."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Pain: "The ache in my forearm is only about 3 out of 10; it's the numbness that bothers me."
  • Little finger: "That one's always normal."
  • Palm: "It's in my fingers. The fleshy bit at the base of my thumb feels normal."
  • Weakness: "I don't think I'm weak exactly. I drop things because I can't feel them properly."
  • Neck: "It aches after a long day, but there's no pain shooting down my arm when I move my neck, and it moves fine."
  • Face, speech, legs: "Nothing like that, no drooping or slurring, and my legs are fine. It's only ever my hand."
  • Joints: "No swollen joints, and I'm not stiff in the mornings."
  • Thyroid: "I'm not feeling the cold or constipated. I'm tired, but I work long days."
  • Thirst: "I'm not more thirsty and I'm not passing more water."
  • Injuries: "I've never broken my wrist."
  • Skin: "The cracked skin is on the backs of my hands and between my fingers, and it itches."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: well; BMI 30 kg/m²
  • Heart rate: 72 beats per minute, regular; blood pressure 128/80 mmHg
  • Inspection: no thenar muscle wasting; dry, scaly, fissured patches over the backs of both hands and the finger webs (irritant/contact dermatitis); no joint swelling
  • Sensation (right): reduced light touch and pinprick over the palmar thumb, index, middle and radial half of the ring finger; normal over the thenar eminence and little finger
  • Sensation (left): normal
  • Power: thumb abduction (abductor pollicis brevis) 5/5 on both sides; finger abduction 5/5 on both sides; grip normal
  • Tinel's test: positive at the right wrist, tingling into the index and middle fingers; negative on the left
  • Phalen's test: positive on the right at 20 seconds; mildly positive on the left at 50 seconds
  • Carpal compression test: positive on the right
  • Neck: full range of movement; Spurling's test negative
  • Upper limb reflexes: normal and symmetrical
  • Wrists: full range, no synovitis
  • Thyroid: no goitre

Investigations

  • TSH: 2.4 mU/L; free T4 14 pmol/L (normal thyroid function)
  • HbA1c: 37 mmol/mol (normal, no diabetes)
  • Full blood count: Hb 132 g/L, normal indices
  • Nerve conduction studies (arranged because symptoms are frequent and to grade severity): right median nerve with prolonged distal sensory latency, slowed sensory conduction across the wrist and mildly prolonged distal motor latency; ulnar nerve normal (moderate right carpal tunnel syndrome). Left median sensory conduction borderline (mild).

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Carpal tunnel syndrome, moderate on the right and mild on the left

    • Evidence: four months of nocturnal paraesthesia in the median distribution relieved by shaking the hand, symptoms provoked by sustained wrist flexion and gripping at work, sensory loss over the palmar thumb, index, middle and radial ring finger sparing the thenar eminence, positive Tinel's, Phalen's and carpal compression tests, and nerve conduction studies showing slowing across the wrist. Risk factors: repetitive wrist work, raised BMI and the menopausal transition.
  • Differentials:

    • C6/C7 cervical radiculopathy: she has neck ache, but no radicular pain, a full neck range, a negative Spurling's test, normal reflexes and a spared thenar eminence (the palmar cutaneous branch leaves the median nerve before the carpal tunnel).
    • Ulnar neuropathy: the little finger and ulnar-supplied muscles are normal.
    • Stroke or TIA: her worry from her aunt's history; but the symptoms are positional, nocturnal, relieved by shaking and confined to a nerve distribution, with no facial, speech or other limb involvement.
    • Inflammatory arthritis or tenosynovitis: no synovitis or morning stiffness.
    • Hand dermatitis: a red herring; it affects the skin of both hands and does not cause numbness in a nerve distribution.

Management

  • Explain the diagnosis: pressure on the median nerve at the wrist, not her neck and not a stroke; symptoms sometimes settle, and simple measures help most people.
  • Activity changes: regular breaks, avoid sustained wrist flexion, alternate tasks, and consider lighter, ergonomic scissors.
  • Night wrist splint holding the wrist in neutral, worn at night for at least 4 weeks and up to 8 weeks.
  • If symptoms persist despite splinting, or for quicker short-term relief, offer a corticosteroid injection into the carpal tunnel (for example methylprednisolone acetate 40 mg), explaining that relief may be temporary.
  • Do not offer NSAIDs, diuretics or vitamin B6: they do not help carpal tunnel syndrome.
  • Refer to hand surgery for carpal tunnel decompression if symptoms persist after conservative treatment, or sooner if numbness becomes constant or thenar wasting or weakness develops.
  • Discuss weight as a contributing factor.
  • Treat the hand dermatitis separately: emollients, gloves for dyes and shampoos, and dermatology referral for patch testing if it persists.
  • Safety-net: return if numbness becomes constant, the thumb weakens or the muscle wastes; seek emergency help for face or arm weakness or speech problems.

Key Learning Points

  • The sensory loss of carpal tunnel syndrome covers the palmar thumb, index, middle and radial ring finger and spares the thenar eminence, which helps separate it from a C6 radiculopathy.
  • Night-time paraesthesia relieved by shaking the hand is the classic history; Tinel's and Phalen's tests support it, and nerve conduction studies grade severity and are needed before surgery rather than to make a typical diagnosis.
  • Treatment is a ladder: splint, then steroid injection, then surgical decompression. Thenar wasting, weakness or constant numbness need surgical referral without waiting.