Musculoskeletal · Case 8

Musculoskeletal OSCE - Rotator Cuff Tear

Diagnosis: Rotator Cuff Tear

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 56-year-old male
  • Occupation: Self-employed painter and decorator
  • Setting: Fracture clinic, 10 days after an emergency department visit
  • Chief complaint: "I can't lift my arm since I fell off the ladder"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 56, I've been a painter and decorator all my working life, I'm right-handed and I run my own small business.

What Brings Me In

"I fell off a stepladder ten days ago and landed on my right arm. They said nothing was broken, but I still can't lift the arm up, and I can't work like this."

My Story

Ten days ago I was painting a ceiling when the stepladder wobbled and I came off from about a metre up. I put my right arm out to save myself and landed on my hand with the arm straight. I got a sharp, tearing pain at the top and outside of my shoulder straight away and couldn't lift the arm afterwards. I didn't hit my head or black out — the ladder just tipped. My wife drove me to the emergency department, where they X-rayed it, said nothing was broken, gave me a sling and painkillers and told me to come to this clinic.

The pain has eased from an 8 to about a 4 out of 10, but the arm still won't do what I tell it. I can't lift it out to the side or above shoulder height — I have to lift it with my left hand. If someone else lifts it up, it goes up, but it drops when they let go. Reaching into a cupboard or holding a brush out is impossible. It aches at night and I can't lie on that side. The shoulder didn't feel like it came out of its socket.

For a year or two before this, the shoulder ached after long days painting ceilings, but it always worked properly. My neck gets stiff from looking up all day, and it's been a bit stiffer since the fall. I've had a big bruise down the outside of my upper arm, which is going yellow now.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: type 2 diabetes for 6 years; high blood pressure; no previous shoulder injury or operation
  • Medications: metformin 1 g twice daily; ramipril 5 mg once daily; paracetamol and codeine from the emergency department (I've been taking paracetamol, but the codeine bunged me up so I stopped it)
  • Allergies: none known
  • Social: smokes about 10 cigarettes a day for 35 years; 10–12 units of alcohol a week; lives with my wife; self-employed with one apprentice; drives a van
  • Family history: father had diabetes; nothing else relevant

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I reckon I've torn something, because they said it wasn't broken but the arm just doesn't work."
  • "I'm worried I won't be able to go back up a ladder. If I can't work, the business goes, and I've got jobs booked for weeks."
  • "I want to know what's wrong and how quickly it can be fixed. If it needs an operation, I'd rather get it done."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Pain: "At the top and outside of the shoulder, sometimes down to the elbow. It was sharp at first, now more of a deep ache, about 4 out of 10."
  • Night pain: "Yes, it wakes me if I roll onto it."
  • Numbness: "The skin on the outside of my shoulder feels normal and my fingers are fine."
  • Neck: "Stiff, but there's no pain running down my arm when I move my neck."
  • Dislocation: "It never felt like it popped out."
  • Other injuries: "No, I didn't hurt my head, wrist or anything else."
  • Stiffness: "If you lift it for me, it moves all right — it's just that I can't lift it myself."
  • Fevers: "No, I've felt well in myself."
  • Left shoulder: "That one's fine."
  • Diabetes: "My sugars have been all right; my last check was okay."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • Heart rate: 76 beats per minute, regular; blood pressure 136/84 mmHg; temperature 36.6 °C
  • Inspection: normal contour of the right shoulder; fading bruise over the lateral upper arm; no obvious muscle wasting yet
  • Palpation: tender just below the anterolateral acromion over the greater tuberosity; acromioclavicular joint and clavicle non-tender
  • Active range (right): abduction to 60° only, forward flexion to 70°
  • Passive range (right): abduction to 160° and full external rotation, painful at the end of range
  • Drop arm test: positive on the right
  • Jobe's (empty can) test: weak (3/5) and painful on the right
  • External rotation: power 4-/5 with a positive external rotation lag sign of about 20°
  • Lift-off and belly press tests: normal (subscapularis intact)
  • Neurovascular: normal sensation over the lateral upper arm (axillary nerve), deltoid contracts, radial pulse present, normal sensation and power in the hand
  • Neck: full range; Spurling's test negative; upper limb reflexes normal
  • Left shoulder: normal

Investigations

  • X-rays of the right shoulder (emergency department, AP and Y views): no fracture, glenohumeral joint congruent, no dislocation; acromiohumeral interval 8 mm (normal); mild acromioclavicular joint degeneration
  • Ultrasound of the right shoulder (fracture clinic): full-thickness tear of supraspinatus, 2.2 cm wide, extending into anterior infraspinatus, with 1.5 cm retraction; subscapularis and biceps tendon intact; no fatty atrophy of the muscles
  • HbA1c: 52 mmol/mol (known diabetes, reasonable control)
  • Urea and electrolytes: creatinine 84 µmol/L, eGFR above 90 mL/min/1.73 m², K 4.5 mmol/L

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Acute traumatic full-thickness rotator cuff tear of the right shoulder (supraspinatus extending into infraspinatus)

    • Evidence: fall onto an outstretched right arm in a man over 40, immediate loss of active elevation, weakness of abduction and external rotation with a lag sign and positive drop arm test, preserved passive range, normal X-rays and an ultrasound showing a full-thickness tear. The earlier aches after overhead work suggest an acute tear on a degenerate cuff.
  • Differentials:

    • Proximal humerus or greater tuberosity fracture: X-rays show no fracture, and ultrasound shows an intact tuberosity with a tendon tear.
    • Shoulder dislocation with axillary nerve injury: no dislocation on X-ray, deltoid contracts, and sensation over the lateral upper arm is normal.
    • Frozen shoulder: he has diabetes, but passive range is preserved; frozen shoulder restricts passive external rotation as much as active.
    • C5 radiculopathy: can weaken abduction, but neck range is full, Spurling's test is negative, reflexes and sensation are normal, and ultrasound shows a tear.
    • Subacromial pain without a tear: the earlier aches fit this, but it would not cause a lag sign, a positive drop arm test or a full-thickness tear on ultrasound.

Management

  • Explain the diagnosis: a tendon has torn away from the bone and will not heal back on its own in this position; nothing is broken.
  • Refer urgently to the shoulder surgeons. In an active working patient, an acute traumatic tear does best with early repair, within weeks of the injury, before the tendon retracts further and the muscle wastes.
  • While waiting: use the sling for comfort only and come out of it several times a day; physiotherapy for gentle pendulum and passive range exercises to prevent stiffness; no lifting, ladders or overhead work.
  • Analgesia: regular paracetamol 1 g four times a day; ibuprofen 400 mg three times a day with food for a short course, as his renal function is normal on ramipril, with a recheck of U&E if it continues beyond a week or two.
  • Smoking cessation: offer support, as smoking raises the risk of the repair failing.
  • Keep diabetes well controlled before surgery and flag it at pre-operative assessment.
  • Work: give a fit note; after repair expect about 4 to 6 weeks in a sling and around 4 to 6 months before returning to heavy overhead work. He may need help keeping the business running meanwhile.
  • Safety-net: return early for new numbness or weakness in the arm, worsening pain or fever.

Key Learning Points

  • After a fall onto an outstretched arm in someone over 40, inability to lift the arm actively with a preserved passive range is a rotator cuff tear until proven otherwise, even with normal X-rays.
  • Always examine the axillary nerve (deltoid and the sensation over the lateral upper arm) after shoulder trauma, and look for a missed dislocation.
  • Acute traumatic tears in active patients need prompt surgical referral, unlike chronic degenerative tears, which are usually managed with physiotherapy first.