Shortness of Breath · Case 11

Shortness of Breath OSCE - Malignant Pleural Effusion

Diagnosis: Malignant Pleural Effusion

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 69-year-old male
  • Occupation: Retired builder
  • Setting: Respiratory clinic (urgent suspected cancer appointment), referred by his GP after a chest X-ray showed a large right pleural effusion
  • Chief complaint: "I get out of breath doing next to nothing"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 69, I was a builder all my working life, and I live with my wife.

What Brings Me In

"My breathing's been getting worse for about three months, and I've lost a fair bit of weight without trying. The GP sent me here after my X-ray."

My Story

About three months ago I noticed I was getting out of breath walking up the hill to the shops. Now I'm puffed after one flight of stairs or about 50 metres on the flat before I have to stop. I've got a dull, heavy ache on the right side of my chest, low down and round towards my back. It's there most of the time, about 4 out of 10, it doesn't change when I breathe in, and some nights it wakes me up. I've lost about 7 kilos in three months, my belt's gone in two notches, and I've gone off my food. I've had a dry, tickly cough and a few sweaty nights.

About six weeks ago the GP thought I had a chest infection and gave me a week of amoxicillin, but it made no difference to my breathing. My ankles are a bit puffy by the evening, but that's been the case since they started my blood pressure tablet two years ago. My brother had heart failure, so I've been wondering if it's my heart.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: high blood pressure; arthritis in both knees; no previous lung problems or cancer
  • Medications: amlodipine 10 mg once daily (ankles swelled when it was started); paracetamol when needed for his knees; finished a week of amoxicillin six weeks ago
  • Allergies: none known
  • Smoking: 20 a day from age 16 to 59 (about 43 pack-years); stopped 10 years ago
  • Occupation: builder for over 40 years; in the 1970s and 1980s he cut and drilled asbestos cement sheets and ripped out old pipe lagging, usually without a mask ("the dust used to cover us")
  • Alcohol: about 10 units a week
  • Social: lives with his wife in a house with stairs; independent; goes fishing at weekends
  • Family history: brother had heart failure in his seventies; no lung cancer in the family

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I thought it was a chest infection that won't shift, or my heart, like my brother."
  • "With the weight I've lost, deep down I'm worried it's cancer. A couple of the lads I worked with died of something from the asbestos."
  • "I want to know what it is, and whether you can drain it so I can breathe."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Breathless at rest: "Not sitting still, only when I move about."
  • Lying flat: "I can lie flat, I just prefer my right side. I don't wake up gasping."
  • Chest pain: "A dull ache, right side, low down and round to the back. It doesn't catch when I breathe in."
  • Cough: "Dry. Nothing comes up, and never any blood."
  • Fever and sweats: "No temperatures. I've woken up damp a few nights, not soaked."
  • Weight and appetite: "Seven kilos in three months. I just don't fancy my food."
  • Voice and swallowing: "My voice is normal and I can swallow fine."
  • Lumps: "I haven't found any lumps in my neck or anywhere else."
  • Legs: "Both ankles puff up a bit by bedtime, same as for two years. No pain in my calves." (red herring)
  • Chest infection: "The antibiotics didn't change anything." (red herring)
  • Heart: "No palpitations, no chest pain on exertion." (red herring: brother's heart failure)
  • Travel and TB contacts: "Never been abroad for long, and I don't know anyone who's had TB."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: thin, comfortable at rest, breathless after walking into the clinic room; weight 71 kg (78 kg three months ago), BMI 21
  • Vitals: heart rate 96 bpm regular, blood pressure 138/84 mmHg, respiratory rate 22/min, SpO2 94% on room air, temperature 36.8 °C
  • Hands and neck: no clubbing; no cervical or supraclavicular lymphadenopathy
  • Trachea: central
  • Chest: reduced expansion on the right; stony dull percussion from the right base to the mid-zone; absent breath sounds and reduced vocal resonance over the same area; left side normal
  • Cardiovascular: heart sounds normal, JVP not raised
  • Legs: mild bilateral pitting oedema at the ankles only; calves soft and non-tender
  • Abdomen: soft, no hepatomegaly or masses

Investigations

  • Chest X-ray (GP, 2 weeks ago): large right pleural effusion up to the mid-zone without mediastinal shift; left lung clear
  • Thoracic ultrasound: large right effusion, no septations; nodular thickening of the diaphragmatic pleura
  • Diagnostic pleural aspiration (ultrasound-guided): blood-stained straw-coloured fluid; protein 44 g/L (serum 68 g/L, ratio 0.65); LDH 420 U/L (serum 210 U/L, ratio 2.0); exudate by Light's criteria; glucose 4.2 mmol/L; pH 7.35; Gram stain and culture negative; acid-fast bacilli not seen (TB culture pending); cytology: atypical mesothelial cells, not diagnostic of malignancy
  • CT thorax with contrast (before drainage): right effusion with nodular pleural thickening over 1 cm, involving the mediastinal pleura; calcified pleural plaques on both sides (past asbestos exposure); no lung mass, no enlarged lymph nodes, no liver or adrenal lesions
  • Local anaesthetic thoracoscopy with pleural biopsies: epithelioid malignant pleural mesothelioma on histology and immunohistochemistry; the lung re-expanded fully once the fluid was removed
  • Bloods: Hb 124 g/L, WCC 8.4 x10^9/L, platelets 438 x10^9/L (mild thrombocytosis), CRP 31 mg/L, albumin 33 g/L, Na 136 mmol/L, creatinine 84 µmol/L, adjusted calcium 2.39 mmol/L, liver tests normal
  • NT-proBNP: 160 ng/L (below 400; heart failure unlikely)
  • ECG: sinus rhythm 94 bpm, normal

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Right-sided malignant pleural effusion caused by epithelioid malignant pleural mesothelioma

    • Evidence: heavy asbestos exposure 40 to 50 years ago; progressive breathlessness, dull chest wall pain and 7 kg weight loss; signs of a large right effusion; blood-stained exudate; nodular mediastinal pleural thickening and pleural plaques on CT; mesothelioma on pleural biopsy.
  • Differentials:

    • Lung cancer with pleural spread: he smoked heavily, but CT shows no lung mass or nodes, and the biopsy shows mesothelioma.
    • Parapneumonic effusion or empyema: he was treated for a chest infection, but has no fever, the fluid pH is normal with negative Gram stain and culture, and antibiotics changed nothing.
    • Heart failure: his brother's history and ankle swelling raise it, but the effusion is one-sided and an exudate, the JVP is normal and NT-proBNP is normal; amlodipine explains the ankles.
    • Tuberculous pleuritis: an exudate with weight loss and sweats fits, but he has no TB contacts or travel, and the biopsy shows a malignant cause.
    • Benign asbestos pleural effusion: the exposure fits, but it does not cause nodular pleural thickening or this weight loss, and the biopsy is malignant.

Management

  • Share the diagnosis honestly and in stages, with his wife present if he wishes; introduce a specialist nurse as his key worker.
  • Relieve breathlessness now with a therapeutic aspiration of no more than 1.5 L at one sitting, to avoid re-expansion pulmonary oedema.
  • Plan definitive fluid control, because a malignant effusion recurs: his lung re-expands, so offer talc pleurodesis (poudrage at thoracoscopy or slurry via a chest drain) or an indwelling pleural catheter, guided by his preference. A catheter is preferred if the lung is trapped.
  • Discuss at the mesothelioma multidisciplinary team meeting; oncology referral for systemic treatment (first-line immunotherapy or platinum-based chemotherapy with pemetrexed) if his fitness allows.
  • Symptom control: regular paracetamol, adding an opioid for chest wall pain; low-dose oral morphine for breathlessness; early referral to palliative care.
  • Mesothelioma from work exposure is a prescribed industrial disease: signpost him to benefits and compensation advice. In time, explain that a death from mesothelioma is reported to the coroner.
  • Review amlodipine if the ankle swelling bothers him.
  • Safety-net: worsening breathlessness, fever, or coughing blood means urgent review.

Key Learning Points

  • Pleural fluid cytology is negative in many mesotheliomas. A negative or equivocal cytology does not exclude cancer, and nodular, circumferential or mediastinal pleural thickening on CT needs a pleural biopsy.
  • Take a full occupational history in anyone with pleural disease: mesothelioma appears 30 to 40 years or more after asbestos exposure, and pleural plaques mark that exposure.
  • Malignant effusions come back. Relieve symptoms with aspiration of up to 1.5 L, then plan definitive treatment (talc pleurodesis or an indwelling pleural catheter) according to whether the lung re-expands and what the patient wants.