Shortness of Breath · Case 9

Shortness of Breath OSCE - Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis

Diagnosis: Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis

Simulate this case

Case Overview

  • Age/Sex: 74-year-old male
  • Occupation: Retired postman
  • Setting: GP surgery, routine appointment; his wife persuaded him to come
  • Chief complaint: "My breathing's not what it was, and I can't shake this cough"

Patient Script

Who I Am

I'm 74, I was a postman for 40 years, and I live with my wife and our dog.

What Brings Me In

"I've been getting more and more out of breath for about a year and a half, and I've had a dry cough the whole time."

My Story

It started about 18 months ago. I noticed I was puffing on hills when I walked the dog, and I put it down to getting older and the bit of weight I'd put on. It's slowly got worse since. Now I have to stop after about 100 metres on the flat, and I'm breathless climbing one flight of stairs or getting dressed in a hurry. There have been no sudden bad spells; it's just a steady downhill. I've had a dry, hacking cough most days for the same 18 months. Nothing comes up. It's worse when I talk a lot or laugh.

I had COVID about two years ago. It was mild, a week in bed, and I was back walking the dog after a fortnight. My neighbour reckons this is long COVID. I've also been on ramipril for my blood pressure for about three years, and I read that it can cause a cough. My knees ache in the mornings, which the GP said is wear and tear. My wife says the ends of my fingers have gone a funny shape. I've lost about 3 kg over the past year without trying.

My Medical Background

  • Past medical history: high blood pressure (3 years); acid reflux for about 10 years; osteoarthritis of both knees; no heart disease, asthma or previous lung problems
  • Medications: ramipril 5 mg once daily; omeprazole 20 mg once daily; atorvastatin 20 mg at night; paracetamol when needed for my knees; no other regular or long-term medicines
  • Allergies: none known
  • Smoking: 20 a day from age 18 to 50 (32 pack-years); stopped 24 years ago
  • Occupation: postman; never worked with asbestos, stone or metal dust, or on farms
  • Home: no birds, no feather pillows or duvets, no damp or mould
  • Alcohol: about 8 units a week
  • Social: lives with my wife in a bungalow; independent; walks the dog twice a day
  • Family history: father died of a stroke at 80; no lung disease in the family

What I Think & Worry About

  • "I thought it was my age and the extra weight, or that long COVID thing, or the blood pressure tablet."
  • "My wife's worried because it isn't getting better. I smoked for years, so I'm worried it's cancer."
  • "I'd like something for the cough and to get some puff back so I can keep walking the dog."

If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...

  • Breathless at rest or at night: "Not sitting down. I can lie flat and I don't wake up gasping."
  • Sputum or blood: "Nothing comes up, and never any blood."
  • Wheeze: "No wheezing."
  • Chest pain: "No pain."
  • Fevers or sweats: "No temperatures or sweats."
  • Weight: "About 3 kg in a year. My appetite's fine."
  • Ankles: "No swelling."
  • Joints: "Both knees ache first thing for ten minutes, but they never swell, and my hands are fine." (red herring)
  • Skin and fingers: "No rashes. My fingers don't go white in the cold. The skin on my hands isn't tight."
  • Swallowing, dry eyes or dry mouth: "No. The reflux is fine on the tablet."
  • Muscles: "No weakness. I can get out of a chair fine."
  • Fingers: "My wife noticed the ends look fatter and the nails curve over."
  • Blood pressure tablet: "I'd been on it over a year before the cough started." (red herring)
  • COVID: "It was mild and I was fully back to normal for months afterwards." (red herring)
  • Voice: "No hoarseness."

Clinical Summary

Examination

  • General: comfortable at rest, speaking in full sentences; breathless after walking in from the waiting room; BMI 28 kg/m²
  • Hands: finger clubbing (loss of the nail-bed angle); no tar staining, joint swelling or sclerodactyly
  • Vitals: heart rate 88 bpm regular, blood pressure 138/82 mmHg, respiratory rate 18/min, SpO2 95% on room air at rest, falling to 88% after a 1-minute sit-to-stand test; temperature 36.6 °C
  • Cardiovascular: JVP not raised, heart sounds normal, no loud second sound, no ankle oedema
  • Chest: expansion mildly reduced on both sides; percussion resonant; fine end-inspiratory crackles at both bases and into the mid-zones posteriorly, unchanged by coughing; no wheeze
  • Knees: crepitus, no effusion or warmth
  • No lymphadenopathy

Investigations

  • Chest X-ray: bilateral reticular shadowing, mostly peripheral and in the lower zones; small lung volumes; no mass or effusion
  • Spirometry: FEV1 2.15 L (80% predicted), FVC 2.40 L (68% predicted), FEV1/FVC 0.90 (restrictive pattern, not obstructive)
  • Full lung function (hospital): TLCO 46% predicted (reduced gas transfer)
  • HRCT chest: subpleural, basal-predominant reticulation with honeycombing and traction bronchiectasis; little ground glass; no mosaic attenuation or air trapping; no pleural plaques (typical usual interstitial pneumonia pattern)
  • Bloods: Hb 141 g/L, WCC 7.2 x10^9/L, CRP 4 mg/L, creatinine 92 µmol/L, liver tests normal, creatine kinase 110 U/L (normal)
  • Autoimmune screen: ANA negative, rheumatoid factor negative, anti-CCP negative
  • NT-proBNP: 210 ng/L (below 400; heart failure unlikely)
  • ECG: sinus rhythm 86 bpm, normal
  • Echocardiogram: normal left ventricular function; estimated pulmonary artery systolic pressure 30 mmHg (no pulmonary hypertension)

Diagnosis

  • Primary diagnosis: Idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, agreed at the interstitial lung disease multidisciplinary meeting

    • Evidence: older male ex-smoker; 18 months of progressive exertional breathlessness and dry cough; clubbing; bibasal fine end-inspiratory crackles; desaturation on exertion; restrictive spirometry with low gas transfer; typical usual interstitial pneumonia pattern on HRCT; no connective tissue disease, exposure or drug cause.
  • Differentials:

    • COPD: he is an ex-smoker, but spirometry is restrictive with a normal FEV1/FVC ratio and there is no wheeze.
    • Heart failure: crackles and breathlessness fit, but he has no orthopnoea or oedema, a normal JVP and NT-proBNP, and a normal echo.
    • Connective tissue disease-associated lung disease: his knees ache, but the pattern is osteoarthritis without synovitis, autoantibodies are negative, and he has no Raynaud's, rash or weakness.
    • Lung cancer: smoking and weight loss raise it, but neither the X-ray nor HRCT shows a mass.
    • Post-COVID lung disease or ACE inhibitor cough: COVID was mild and he had recovered fully months before symptoms began, and an ACE inhibitor cough does not cause clubbing, crackles or a restrictive defect.

Management

  • In general practice: urgent referral to the respiratory interstitial lung disease clinic because of crackles, clubbing and progressive breathlessness; arrange chest X-ray, spirometry and blood tests while he waits.
  • Diagnosis at the specialist multidisciplinary meeting. With a typical HRCT pattern and other causes excluded, a lung biopsy is not needed.
  • Antifibrotic treatment (pirfenidone or nintedanib) from the specialist centre, according to his FVC; it slows the fall in lung function. Monitor liver tests and warn about gut side effects and, with pirfenidone, sun sensitivity.
  • Do not give prednisolone with azathioprine and N-acetylcysteine: that combination harms people with this disease.
  • Pulmonary rehabilitation.
  • Formal assessment for ambulatory oxygen, because he desaturates on exertion.
  • Vaccinations: annual influenza, pneumococcal and COVID boosters.
  • Continue omeprazole for reflux. A trial switch from ramipril to an angiotensin receptor blocker will show whether any of the cough is drug-related.
  • Talk honestly about prognosis: a progressive disease, with median survival of about 3 to 5 years from diagnosis and wide variation. Begin advance care planning and involve palliative care as symptoms progress; low-dose oral morphine can help refractory breathlessness and cough later.
  • Repeat lung function every 3 to 6 months; seek urgent review for a sudden worsening over days, which may be an acute exacerbation.

Key Learning Points

  • Fine bibasal end-inspiratory crackles and clubbing in an older patient with progressive breathlessness should prompt an HRCT. Early symptoms are often blamed on age, weight, an old infection or a medicine.
  • IPF is diagnosed by a multidisciplinary team: a typical usual interstitial pneumonia pattern on HRCT is enough once connective tissue disease, exposures and drugs are excluded.
  • Antifibrotics slow decline but do not reverse fibrosis, and steroid combinations are harmful. Pulmonary rehabilitation, oxygen, vaccination and early palliative planning matter as much as drugs.