Singapore Family Medicine · Case 1
Singapore Family Medicine OSCE - Dementia with Caregiver Strain
Diagnosis: Dementia with Caregiver Strain
Best done before you read the answer.
Case Overview
- Age/Sex: 81-year-old male, history from his daughter (52)
- Occupation: Retired hawker
- Setting: GP clinic in Singapore; his daughter is seen first while he waits outside
- Chief complaint: "My father keeps forgetting things, and I can't cope any more"
How you're marked
History taking mark scheme
Starting the consultation
- Introduce yourself by name and role
- Confirm who you are speaking to
- Explain the purpose of the consultation and gain consent to go on
- Open with an open question
The presenting complaint
- Establish when it started and how it has changed
- Explore the main symptom in detail
- Ask about associated symptoms
- Screen for red flags
The patient's perspective
- Ask what the patient thinks is causing it
- Ask what worries the patient most
- Ask what the patient hopes will happen
- Ask how it is affecting their daily life
Background
- Take a past medical and surgical history
- Take a drug history and ask about allergies
- Ask about family history
- Take a social history
Structure and rapport
- Signpost when you change topic
- Summarise and check you have it right
- Respond to emotion with empathy
Closing
- Explain what happens next
- Safety-net and invite questions
Presentation
- Give the most likely diagnosis, your reasoning and a differential
- Give a safe initial plan
Plus 7 points specific to this case, shown after marking.
Show what the patient will say
Patient Script
Who I Am
I'm his daughter, 52, an accounts clerk, and I've lived with my father in his flat since my mother died 3 years ago; my brother works overseas.
What Brings Me In
It's about my father. His memory is getting worse, and last week he got lost. I don't know how much longer I can manage like this.
My Story
About 2 years ago he started repeating the same questions and misplacing his keys and wallet. He accused me of hiding his money. At first I thought it was just old age. It has got slowly worse; there was never a day when he suddenly changed.
In the last 6 months he can't manage money any more. He paid the same bill twice, and 2 months ago he gave 2,000 dollars to a scam caller who said he was from the bank. He stopped going to the coffee shop to play chess because he can't follow the game. Three months ago he left a pot on the stove and it burned dry; luckily I came home.
Last Tuesday he went to the market at 6 am and didn't come back. The police found him 5 hours later at a bus interchange far from home. He couldn't tell them his address. At night he wakes up and wanders, packs a bag and says he wants to "go home to the village". Sometimes he calls me by my mother's name. He still showers and eats himself, but he needs reminding and wears the same clothes for days.
As for me, I sleep about 4 hours a night. I've used up my leave and took unpaid leave last week. I cry in the toilet at work. Two nights ago I shouted at him and I felt terrible. My brother sends money but he isn't here.
My Medical Background
- His past history: high blood pressure, high cholesterol, poor hearing (he won't wear his hearing aid), cataract operation 5 years ago; no stroke or head injury
- A fall at home 4 months ago: tripped on the rug, didn't hit his head, didn't black out, got up himself
- His medications: amlodipine 5 mg once a day, simvastatin 20 mg at night; I give them to him now
- Allergies: none
- Social: sold fried noodles at a hawker stall for 40 years; primary school education; speaks Hokkien and some Mandarin; smoked until 70; no alcohol
- Family: his elder sister became very forgetful in old age
- He has a Pioneer Generation card. He has not made a Lasting Power of Attorney.
What I Think & Worry About
- I think it's old age, but I'm scared it's Alzheimer's.
- I'm worried he'll get lost again or start a fire, and about losing my job.
- I promised my mother I would never put him in a home, so I feel guilty even thinking about it.
- I hope for a specialist referral, something to help him sleep at night, and to know what help there is.
If You Ask Me About Other Symptoms...
- Sudden change or good and bad days: "No, it's been slowly going down. No day he was suddenly much worse."
- Infection: "He had a small cough last month, it went away. No fever. No burning or smelly urine."
- Mood: "He's quieter, but he still laughs at his Hokkien drama and eats well."
- Seeing things: "No, he doesn't see people or animals that aren't there."
- Walking and shaking: "Slower, but steady. No shuffling, no shaking hands."
- Wetting himself: "No."
- Weakness or speech: "No weakness, no slurred speech."
- Behaviour: "Still polite to the neighbours. He gets angry when I stop him going out at night, but he has never hit me."
- His driving: "He never drove."
- My own mood: "I feel low most days and exhausted. No, I would never hurt myself or him."
Show the answerExamination, results, diagnosis and management
Clinical Summary
Examination
- Father, seen after his daughter: alert, cooperative, mildly unkempt, hard of hearing
- Blood pressure 138/78 mmHg seated, 134/76 mmHg standing; heart rate 72 bpm regular; temperature 36.7°C; SpO2 98% on air
- Abbreviated Mental Test: 4/10 (impaired; errors included the year, the time, the name of this place and recall of the address)
- Clock drawing: numbers crowded on one side, hands not placed
- Neurological: no focal deficit, normal tone, no tremor, normal gait
- Hearing: whispered voice test failed on both sides; no wax
- Geriatric Depression Scale (15-item): 3 (not suggestive of depression)
Investigations
- Full blood count: haemoglobin 131 g/L, normal white cells and platelets
- Sodium 139 mmol/L, creatinine 98 µmol/L, eGFR 62 mL/min/1.73 m2
- Corrected calcium: 2.35 mmol/L (normal)
- Fasting glucose: 5.4 mmol/L
- TSH: 2.1 mU/L (normal)
- Vitamin B12: 345 pmol/L; folate normal
- Liver function: normal
- Syphilis serology: non-reactive
- Urine dipstick: negative
- CT brain: to be arranged by the memory clinic, to exclude a subdural haematoma or other structural cause
- Daughter, Zarit Burden Interview: 46 (moderate to severe caregiver burden)
Diagnosis
Primary diagnosis: probable dementia, most likely Alzheimer's disease, with night-time wandering and agitation, and severe strain in his daughter as sole caregiver.
- Evidence: insidious, progressive decline over 2 years, memory first, then money handling, judgement and orientation; getting lost, the stove incident and the scam; AMT 4/10 and an abnormal clock; reversible causes screened negative.
Differentials:
- Delirium: no acute onset or fluctuation, no infection, normal observations and urine.
- Depression with cognitive impairment: GDS 3, eating well and still enjoying his drama.
- Vascular dementia: hypertension is a risk factor, but there is no stepwise decline or stroke history; mixed disease is possible.
- Subdural haematoma after the fall: the decline started well before the fall, with no step change and no focal signs; CT will confirm.
- Hearing loss: worsens communication, but does not explain getting lost, the stove or the scam.
- Dementia with Lewy bodies or frontotemporal dementia: no hallucinations, parkinsonism or early personality change.
Management
- Tell the daughter, kindly, that this looks like dementia, which needs specialist confirmation; acknowledge how much she is carrying.
- Bloods as above; refer to a memory clinic or geriatric service at a public hospital (subsidised referral) for diagnosis, CT brain and consideration of a cholinesterase inhibitor such as donepezil.
- Safety: an identity card in his pocket with her number, a GPS tracker or locator, informing neighbours; a gas cut-off or induction cooker; protecting his bank accounts from scams.
- Night wandering: daytime activity and light, a regular routine; avoid sedatives and antipsychotics, which raise the risk of falls, confusion and death.
- Lasting Power of Attorney now, if he still has the capacity to make one, certified by an accredited doctor or a psychiatrist; if he no longer has capacity, she can apply to the court to be his deputy.
- Support for her: dementia day care, home personal care, caregiver training and support groups, a medical social worker to check what he qualifies for: the Caregivers Training Grant, the levy concession for a migrant domestic worker (he is over 67), Pioneer Generation subsidies, and the Home Caregiving Grant once he needs help with at least 3 daily activities.
- Her own health: offer her an appointment for her low mood and sleep; screen for depression; respite care.
- Audiology review for his hearing aid.
- Review in 2 weeks with the results, and earlier if he becomes suddenly more confused.
Key Learning Points
- Tell dementia (insidious, progressive) from delirium (acute, fluctuating) and depression, and screen reversible causes before referral.
- The caregiver is a patient too: assess burden, mood and safety, and offer practical respite, financial and legal support.
- Manage behaviour with non-drug measures first; sedatives and antipsychotics carry real harm in dementia.